In this comparison video, Classic Firearms examine the differences between the original SCAR 17 and the new Gen 2 model. The latest version introduces several modern updates, including a full M-LOK rail that replaces the older Picatinny style, providing more space for accessories and a more rigid feel. They also note that the front sights are no longer integrated into the gas block, opting instead for Magpul flip-ups, which might disappoint those who enjoy the classic look but simplifies the overall design.

The shooting experience reveals the most significant changes, particularly regarding the internal mechanics. The Gen 2 features a lightened bolt carrier group and a new hydraulic buffer system designed to reduce the mechanical vibration often felt in the older model. During live fire, the hosts describe the original rifle as having a thumpy recoil that can practically rattle your teeth, while the updated version feels much smoother and more controlled, making it feel less like a workout and more like a modern precision tool.

While the rifle still features the famous Ugg boot stock and its unique shades of flat dark earth, the hosts conclude that the functional upgrades justify the high price tag. The improved controls, better furniture, and reduced recoil make it a solid choice for those who want a high-end rifle that won't require immediate jaw surgery after a day at the range. It remains a show-off piece for the cool dad on the block, even if it still refuses to use standard magazines.